Musa
The New Orleans Saints have wasted no time making a pivotal quarterback decision in the wake of Derek Carr’s unexpected retirement. While many speculated that rookie Tyler Shough would have a real opportunity to compete for the starting job, the team has instead turned to veteran Jameis Winston, signaling a clear lack of confidence in the young gunslinger from Texas Tech.
Shough, who joined the Saints as an undrafted free agent, had impressed in offseason workouts with his size, arm strength, and poise. Many fans hoped the team would give him a legitimate shot to develop and possibly lead a new era in New Orleans. But with the franchise prioritizing experience and immediate stability, Winston’s re-signing — and now elevation to QB1 — makes it clear that Shough is viewed more as a long-term project than a short-term solution.
This move could have long-term implications for Shough’s development. Without consistent first-team reps or meaningful preseason snaps, his chances of climbing the depth chart have taken a significant hit. He’ll now be fighting for a roster spot against other backups and fringe players rather than focusing on growing into a leadership role.
While the decision may provide short-term security for the Saints, it raises questions about the team’s long-term quarterback strategy — and whether a talent like Shough will ever get the opportunity to prove himself in New Orleans. For now, it’s a disappointing twist in what was shaping up to be a promising narrative.
Olaniyi Ayoola
Musa
